Tag: General (Business & Management)

  • Greater reporting quality helps firms win competitive procurement tenders

    What the study found

    The study found that firms with more financial reporting disclosure and higher-quality reporting are more likely to win government contracts in competitive tenders in Japan. It also found that political connections weaken this disclosure–procurement link.

    Why the authors say this matters

    The authors conclude that formal transparency can matter in public procurement, especially under institutional constraints. They also say the findings suggest that reducing political influence and improving disclosure can support fairness and efficiency in procurement.

    What the researchers tested

    The researchers examined Japanese procurement data from 2020 and 2021, using 4,955 firm-years of listed companies that won 6,870 central government tenders from JETRO. They used probit, ordinary least squares, and tobit regressions, separated competitive from non-competitive tenders, and ran sub-sample analyses by political connection. They also used instrumental variables and propensity score matching as robustness checks to address endogeneity.

    What worked and what didn't

    Greater reporting quantity and higher-quality reporting were associated with a higher chance of winning contracts in competitive tenders. No such effect was found in non-competitive tenders. Political connections reduced the strength of the disclosure effect, suggesting a substitution effect.

    What to keep in mind

    The summary does not describe detailed limitations beyond the study’s focus on Japanese central government tenders in 2020 and 2021. The findings are specific to that setting and the abstract does not state whether they apply more broadly.

    • Firms with greater disclosure and better reporting quality were more likely to win competitive government tenders.
    • The disclosure effect was not found in non-competitive tenders.
    • Political connections weakened the link between disclosure and procurement success.
    • The study used Japanese central government tender data from 2020 and 2021.
    • The authors say transparency may improve fairness and efficiency in public procurement.